Authorization

 

Journal

Volume 11, №2, Special Issue on Applied Artificial Intelligence and Soft Computing


Toward Justifying Logically and Socially Acceptable Reasons with Dialectical Proof Theories (pages 227-242)
Hiroyuki Kido, Katsumi Nitta


Abstract. This paper formalizes argument-based reasoning for justifying arguments with believable reasons in terms of nonmonotonic consequences and desirable reasons in terms of Pareto optimality and maximizing social welfare functions. Our unified approach gives a four-layer practical argumentation framework structured with a propositional modal language with defaults and defeasible inference rules associated with practical reasoning. Dialectical proof theories for grounded and credulous preferred semantics of practical argumentation semantics are formalized in order to justify arguments with Pareto optimal, social welfare maximizing and nonmonotonic consequence reasons. Our formalization contributes to extend argument-based reasoning so that it can formally combine reasoning about logical believability and social desirability by benefiting from economic notions.

Keywords: Argumentation, Practical Reasoning, Nonmonotonic Consequences, Pareto Optimality, Social Welfare.

AMS Subject Classification: 68T37.


COIA 2027

7-9 July 2027
Baku, Azerbaijan

Search